Plain Jame Bakery

The recipe index

Every batch begins after your order is confirmed. Open an item for the details, then add priced items to your cart or send a custom request for a quote.

Made for the order at hand

We bake for Hickory and the Catawba Valley with at least 48 hours' notice.

2 items

01 / category

Cookies

Cookies¤18.00

Super Soft Chocolate Chip Cookies

Super soft handmade chocolate chip cookies that will remind you of cookie dough — with the option to add sprinkles, because everything's more fun with a little color.

Open details

CookiesQuote by request

Sugar Cookies

Freshly made sugar cookies that look as good as they taste.

Open details

1 item

02 / category

Bars

Bars¤22.00

Dutch Process Brownies

The ultimate combination of fudgy and light — rich chocolatey flavor without being too rich.

Open details

3 items

03 / category

Muffins & Rolls

Muffins & Rolls¤15.00

Muffins

Moist muffins that feel more like dessert than breakfast. Choose blueberry, strawberry, or pumpkin chocolate chip — other flavors available on request with advance notice.

Open details

Muffins & RollsQuote by request

Pumpkin Rolls

Moist, fluffy pumpkin sheet cake wrapped around handmade cream cheese frosting — the ultimate fall treat.

Open details

Muffins & RollsQuote by request

Dinner Rolls

Super soft dinner rolls that tie together every meal.

Open details

A little more to know

Why folks choose us

Made-to-order baking, local custom requests, and a direct conversation about what you need.

Baked for your order

We begin once your order is confirmed, so nothing is pre-baked or waiting on a shelf.

A real person to talk with

Tell us what you need and we will follow up with a quote and timeline.

Custom requests, close to home

For local occasions in Hickory and the Catawba Valley, tell us what you are celebrating.

Need a different flavor, quantity, or occasion?

Tell us the flavor, quantity, and occasion. We will follow up with a quote and timeline.

Request a custom order Read our FAQ